Why Textual Reasoning?
Introduction
This first issue of the new E-Journal of Textual Reasoning aims to present the current theoretical thinking on the nature and purposes of Textual Reasoning. The editors asked Peter Ochs, Robert Gibbs, and Aryeh Cohen to supply us with representative statements and both members of our society and outside figures have provided us with commentaries. There have been a number of other published attempts to define the presuppositions and purposes of TR, but the present attempt shows both significant development and clarity.
Essays
Why Textual Reasoning?
Robert Gibbs
Why Textual Reasoning?
Aryeh Cohen
Responses
Response to “Why Textual Reasoning?”
Leora Batnitzky
The Ground of Textual Reasoning: A Response to Robert Gibbs
Randi Rashkover
Before the Law: Reflections on Textual (Un)Reasoning
Elliot Wolfson
A Response to Peter Ochs
Zachary Braiterman
Textual Reasoning
David Novak
Fellowship, Recognition and/or Death
Shalom Carmy
Texts, Reason, and Homo Liber, or What I have Learned I’ve Learned through Textual Reasoning, Together
Michael Zank
Responses to Cohen, Gibbs, and Ochs
Hyam Maccoby