"An investigation of the effects of Personal Mastery Counseling on goal" by Lawrence Edward Sutton

Date Awarded

1991

Document Type

Dissertation

Degree Name

Doctor of Education (Ed.D.)

Department

Education

Advisor

John Lavach

Abstract

This study focused on the effectiveness of Personal Mastery Counseling (PMC), a small-group cognitive-behavioral approach to counseling. Thirty 7th grade male volunteers were assigned, 10 subjects per group, to a PMC group, a bibliotherapy group, or a No-Treatment Control group. The PMC group participated in ten 55-minute counseling sessions. The PMC group leader helped the subjects identify and eliminate self-defeating behaviors by teaching them how to set behavioral goals, accept personal responsibility, practice new behaviors, and monitor improvement. The bibliotherapy group participated in ten 55-minute sessions with assigned readings and discussions on eliminating self-defeating behaviors and improving self-concept. The No-Treatment Control group met only for pre- and post-testing.;Academic grade point averages, the Tennessee Self-Concept Scale, and Rotter's I-E Scale were administered pre- and post-treatment. A teacher-completed behavior rating scale and an individualized goal attainment scale were administered post-treatment only. It was hypothesized that the PMC group would show significantly greater improvement in self-concept, locus of control, and grade point average than the bibliotherapy or the control group; that students participating in PMC would receive significantly higher teacher behavior/conduct and class participation ratings than students in the bibliotherapy group; and that students in the PMC group would make more improvement on a goal attainment scale than would be predicted by chance variations.;Data analysis using an analysis of variance did not demonstrate that PMC positively effected self-concept, locus of control, grade point average, or teacher ratings. A Chi-square one-sample test did indicate that PMC students made significantly higher than expected goal attainment scale ratings after treatment.;It was concluded that neither Personal Mastery Counseling nor bibliotherapy significantly effected the self-concept, locus of control, grades, or teacher ratings of 7th grade male students. Personal Mastery Counseling did however help students modify a self-defeating behavior. Several possible reasons were discussed for the failure to obtain hypothesized results with all but one variable.

DOI

https://dx.doi.org/doi:10.25774/w4-5zad-b634

Rights

© The Author

Share

COinS